Algés, Oeiras Mon to Sat · 09:00 to 13:00 and 14:00 to 19:00
WhatsApp Book a consultation
  1. Home
  2. Body aesthetics
  3. Keloid or hypertrophic scar

Keloid or hypertrophic scar: how to tell them apart and when to see a doctor

A raised, firm, red scar? Find out how keloids and hypertrophic scars differ, which factors raise the risk and what treatments exist.

Rúben BritoAuthor
Dr Michelle CampagnoliClinical review · OM no. 69467
7 min read
Uma mulher a tocar numa cicatriz elevada junto à clavícula
In this article
  1. In short
  2. How to tell the difference
  3. Why they form
  4. Prevention: what helps after a wound or surgery
  5. Treatments
  6. When to see a doctor
  7. At Luxmed Clinic
  8. Frequently asked questions

When a wound heals, the body produces collagen to close the skin. In some people this process goes beyond what is needed and forms a raised, firm and sometimes red scar, with itching or pain. It may be a hypertrophic scar or a keloid.

At first glance they look alike, but they behave differently: a hypertrophic scar tends to improve with time, whereas a keloid tends to keep growing and to come back after it is removed (Berman et al., 2017). That is why telling the two apart matters before any treatment.

In 30 seconds

Three ideas to remember.

1A keloid goes beyond the edges of the woundA hypertrophic scar stays within them and tends to flatten in 1 to 2 years; a keloid rarely regresses.
2There are risk factors and ways to prevent themDarker skin, family history and certain body areas raise the risk; silicone is the most recommended preventive measure.
3Surgical removal alone is usually not enoughWith a keloid, surgery on its own has a high recurrence rate and is combined with another treatment.
Imagem opcional · abertura1200 × 800 px
Fica por baixo do resumo, se existir uma segunda foto.

How to tell the difference

FeatureHypertrophic scarKeloid
Boundariesstays within the boundaries of the original woundextends beyond the boundaries and invades the surrounding skin
When it appearsin the first weeks after the woundmay appear weeks or months later, sometimes after a minimal injury
Coursetends to flatten and fade in 1 to 2 yearsrarely regresses; may keep growing
After surgical removalmay improveoften comes back if the surgery is not combined with another treatment
Typical areasjoints, areas of tension, burnsearlobe, chest, shoulders, upper back
Symptomsitching, sometimes painitching and pain more frequent and more intense

In practice it is not always easy to tell them apart, especially in the first months. Some specialists consider that the two are part of a spectrum of the same inflammatory skin disease (Ogawa, 2017).

Why they form

Normal healing goes through an inflammation phase, a collagen production phase and a remodelling phase that can last more than a year. In hypertrophic scars and keloids, inflammation in the deep layer of the skin (the dermis) is prolonged and collagen production becomes uncontrolled (Ogawa, 2017).

Risk factors

For hypertrophic scars (Berman et al., 2017, Ogawa et al., 2019):

  • wounds in areas of tension or movement, such as the chest, shoulders or joints;
  • deep burns;
  • infection or delayed healing;
  • wounds that do not follow the natural lines of the skin.

For keloids (Berman et al., 2017, Ogawa et al., 2019):

  • darker skin;
  • family history of keloids;
  • age between adolescence and 30 years;
  • areas such as the earlobe, chest and shoulders;
  • injuries such as piercings, acne, vaccinations, surgery or small cuts;
  • pregnancy, which can make existing keloids grow.

Anyone who has already had a keloid is more likely to develop others.

Prevention: what helps after a wound or surgery

If you tend to form raised scars, prevention starts as soon as the wound closes (Ogawa et al., 2019, Gold et al., 2014, Mustoe et al., 2002):

  • Silicone gel or sheets: the most recommended preventive measure. It is used for several months, from the moment the skin has closed. The evidence is of limited quality, but international guidelines still regard it as first line (Gold et al., 2014, O'Brien and Jones, 2013).
  • Reduce tension on the scar: suitable adhesive tapes in the first weeks, and avoiding movements that stretch the area.
  • Sun protection: prevents the scar from darkening.
  • Pressure: in extensive burns, compression garments for months.
  • Avoid new injuries in people with a history of keloids: think twice before piercings, tattoos or non-essential cosmetic surgery in risk areas.

Treatments

Treatment depends on the type of scar, its size, its age and the symptoms. Several options are often combined (Berman et al., 2017, Ogawa et al., 2019, Gold et al., 2014).

TreatmentWhat forNotes
Silicone gel or sheetsrecent scars, preventiondaily use for months
Corticosteroid injections into the scarpersistent keloids and hypertrophic scars; first-line treatmentreduce volume, itching and pain; several sessions are usually needed; may cause thinning or lightening of the skin
Cryosurgerysmall keloidsmay lighten the skin, especially in darker skin
Vascular laserredness and volumeworks better on recent scars
Other medicines injected into the scarkeloids that do not respond to corticosteroidssome are used outside the approved indication (off-label); a medical decision
Surgerylarge keloids, hypertrophic scars that limit movementwith a keloid, surgery alone has a high recurrence rate; it should be combined with a corticosteroid or superficial radiotherapy (Berman et al., 2017, Ogawa et al., 2019)
Superficial radiotherapyafter keloid surgeryreduces recurrence; reserved for selected cases

Realistic expectations

  • No treatment makes a scar disappear completely. The aim is to make it flatter, paler, softer and free of symptoms.
  • Hypertrophic scars usually respond better than keloids.
  • Keloids can come back even after good results, and follow-up is important (Berman et al., 2017).
  • Results vary from person to person.

When to see a doctor

Ask for an assessment if

Tick what applies to you.

See a doctor without delay if a raised scar or lesion bleeds, ulcerates, quickly changes colour or shape, or appears with no previous wound. Rarely, a skin cancer can look like a scar and must be ruled out.

If you have any doubts, call SNS 24 (808 24 24 24). If you develop an infection with a high fever, redness that spreads quickly or signs of a severe allergic reaction after a treatment, call 112.

At Luxmed Clinic

At the consultation, we assess the scar, your history and your risk factors, to work out whether it is a hypertrophic scar or a keloid and what the best approach is.

From there, we propose a plan tailored to you, with realistic expectations and based on what the scientific evidence supports. When necessary, we coordinate with dermatology or plastic surgery. If you have an acne scar, see also Acne scars: what types exist and what to expect from treatment.

Talk to us

The assessment is a conversation, with no obligation. Tell us what concerns you and our team will reply.

info@luxmed.pt

This article is for information only and does not replace a medical assessment. Results vary from person to person.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between a keloid and a hypertrophic scar?

A hypertrophic scar stays within the edges of the wound and tends to improve with time. A keloid goes beyond those edges, rarely regresses and often comes back after it is removed.

Does a keloid go away on its own?

Rarely. Unlike a hypertrophic scar, it tends to persist or keep growing.

Can a keloid be removed with surgery?

It can, but surgery on its own has a high recurrence rate. In general, it is combined with corticosteroid injections or superficial radiotherapy.

Does silicone really work?

It is the most recommended preventive measure, although the quality of the studies is limited. It works better on recent scars and with prolonged daily use.

I have keloids. Can I get a piercing or a tattoo?

The risk of forming a new keloid is higher. Talk to a doctor first, especially if it is on the earlobe, chest or shoulders.

Can a scar turn into cancer?

It is very rare. But a lesion that changes, bleeds or ulcerates should be assessed to rule out other causes.

Scientific references 6
  1. Berman B, Maderal A, Raphael B. Keloids and hypertrophic scars: pathophysiology, classification, and treatment. Dermatol Surg. 2017;43(Suppl 1):S3-S18. doi:10.1097/dss.0000000000000819 Artigo
  2. Ogawa R. Keloid and hypertrophic scars are the result of chronic inflammation in the reticular dermis. Int J Mol Sci. 2017;18(3):606. doi:10.3390/ijms18030606 Artigo
  3. Ogawa R, Akita S, Akaishi S, et al. Diagnosis and treatment of keloids and hypertrophic scars: Japan Scar Workshop Consensus Document 2018. Burns Trauma. 2019;7:39. doi:10.1186/s41038-019-0175-y Artigo
  4. Gold MH, Berman B, Clementoni MT, et al. Updated international clinical recommendations on scar management: part 1, evaluating the evidence. Dermatol Surg. 2014;40(8):817-824. Artigo
  5. O'Brien L, Jones DJ. Silicone gel sheeting for preventing and treating hypertrophic and keloid scars. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2013;(9):CD003826. Artigo
  6. Mustoe TA, Cooter RD, Gold MH, et al. International clinical recommendations on scar management. Plast Reconstr Surg. 2002;110(2):560-571. doi:10.1097/00006534-200208000-00031 Artigo
Written byRúben BritoOperial Development
Clinical reviewDr Michelle CampagnoliOM no. 69467 · Doctor with Competence in Aesthetic Medicine.View profile →

Book a consultation

Book your consultation

Choose how you prefer to get in touch. We will arrange the assessment consultation with Dr Michelle Campagnoli.

Booking through the websiteAssessment consultationTalk to our assistant on WhatsApp and ask for the current price of the assessment.

New Life Miraflores, Algés · Office Center, R. Santa Teresa do Menino Jesus n.º 6, 9.º C, 1495-048

Your details are used only for this contact. Any treatment depends on a prior medical assessment.

Request an appointmentIt takes less than a minute.
Speciality
You do not need to go into detail. The doctor will talk to you during the consultation.
Request received. Our team will contact you as soon as possible.
CallAssistantAvailableBook